L takes a while to vote on this one. Eventually, with a frown and a quick shake of his head, it's Category 2... but in this case it's because the punishments seem largely interchangeable for what appears to have been an accomplice role. Any of them might be appropriate, where in the other cases, the proposed punishments seemed insufficient.

He resolves to go talk to Alice during her imprisonment, because something about the whole thing is troubling him.